TEXAS BOYS SOCCER FORUM

CHECK OUT THE NEW TXSOCCER GROUP ON FACEBOOK....come join now!
Visit the Girls Forum at:   www.txsoccer.net
** PLEASE START NEW THREADS WITH AGE GROUP **

Top posters

omega striker (2075)
 
go99 (2013)
 
finish1 (1427)
 
Axxman (982)
 
my2cents (816)
 
The German (815)
 
Ibystander (766)
 
plantit (687)
 
soccerrus2 (647)
 
gababa (572)
 

May 2012

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Calendar Calendar

Rss feeds

Yahoo! 
Google Reader 
MSN 
AOL 
NewsGator 
Netvibes 
Bloglines 

    Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Share

    clueless

    Posts: 445
    Join date: 2009-08-06

    Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  clueless on Fri Dec 04, 2009 12:04 pm

    Did I read that correctly? Texans will have two going to DCup and Solar is out due to Texans taking over the sponsorship of the tournament from the Longhorns.
    If Texans teams are 6th and 7th in D1, they will go to DCup regardless - pretty good recruiting fodder.

    Tequilapark

    Posts: 267
    Join date: 2009-06-22

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Tequilapark on Fri Dec 04, 2009 12:44 pm

    clueless wrote:Did I read that correctly? Texans will have two going to DCup and Solar is out due to Texans taking over the sponsorship of the tournament from the Longhorns.
    If Texans teams are 6th and 7th in D1, they will go to DCup regardless - pretty good recruiting fodder.


    Yes, you are correct. I think this is bull, Solar wins 4th place and they dont go because of sponsorship, basically, the Texans, specifically Hassan's team, go because the club buy's them a spot in the tournament.

    Solar is the first alternative team, FCDB is the second, both those teams are higher in the Classic Legaue standings than Texans Red.

    Cowboys

    Posts: 8
    Join date: 2009-10-04
    Location: name it

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Cowboys on Fri Dec 04, 2009 12:47 pm

    Tequilapark wrote:
    clueless wrote:Did I read that correctly? Texans will have two going to DCup and Solar is out due to Texans taking over the sponsorship of the tournament from the Longhorns.
    If Texans teams are 6th and 7th in D1, they will go to DCup regardless - pretty good recruiting fodder.


    Yes, you are correct. I think this is bull, Solar wins 4th place and they dont go because of sponsorship, basically, the Texans, specifically Hassan's team, go because the club buy's them a spot in the tournament.
    were did you read this
    Solar is the first alternative team, FCDB is the second, both those teams are higher in the Classic Legaue standings than Texans Red.

    Cowboys

    Posts: 8
    Join date: 2009-10-04
    Location: name it

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Cowboys on Fri Dec 04, 2009 12:48 pm

    were did you read this

    True10

    Posts: 492
    Join date: 2009-06-22
    Location: No really, where am I

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  True10 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 2:58 pm

    Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    Last edited by True10 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 3:01 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : pissed off)

    Tequilapark

    Posts: 267
    Join date: 2009-06-22

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Tequilapark on Fri Dec 04, 2009 3:25 pm

    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    True, think you are upset now? wait to see if Solar does get invited because a spot opens up and then its the 1st, 2nd, 3rd 4th and 6th place teams going, and Blue stays home.

    This is crap, especially when these kids have been waiting for the opporutnity to play in Dallas Cup for several years.

    I wonder if this is also affecting other age groups.

    go99

    Posts: 2013
    Join date: 2009-07-09
    Location: Standing next to Klinsmann wispering in his ear.

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  go99 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 3:37 pm

    certianly hurts the credibility of the Dallas cup when you no longer have to earn your way in. Besides I heard that HN was not going to let the tournament take place in the N Texas area if his team was not allowed to play. What about the dignity of that team? Can't earn your way in so sugardaddy buys you a spot. Nice. Next he will be buying refs and the CL, or has he

    Onetime

    Posts: 6
    Join date: 2009-11-12

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Onetime on Fri Dec 04, 2009 3:50 pm

    The kids are upset, they worked hard in winning their last 2 games to qualify, but unfortunately this is the new system we have to live with concerning Dallas Cup. As I told my son, use this as motivation as you continue to develop as a soccer player. One thing I ask, please don't hold this against the kids on 97DTR, they are a great group of kids and parents, and I am sure they will do their best to represent our league at Dallas Cup.

    go99

    Posts: 2013
    Join date: 2009-07-09
    Location: Standing next to Klinsmann wispering in his ear.

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  go99 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 4:01 pm

    I feel bad for the boys, but I am adding this to my stack of things to hold against HN, texans, and the N texas soccer mafia

    True10

    Posts: 492
    Join date: 2009-06-22
    Location: No really, where am I

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  True10 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 4:44 pm

    Nothing against the DTR boys, they did not change the rules. I find it interesting that the past 2 changes to qualifications were made a year in advance but this change had to have been made recently. FCDB unfornately did not win their way in so backing their way in was the only way they were going to get in so if one team is unable to make it and we end left out I am sad but not too upset. Solar worked their way in and they deserve to play.

    True10

    Posts: 492
    Join date: 2009-06-22
    Location: No really, where am I

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  True10 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 4:57 pm

    Tequilapark wrote:
    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    True, think you are upset now? wait to see if Solar does get invited because a spot opens up and then its the 1st, 2nd, 3rd 4th and 6th place teams going, and Blue stays home.

    This is crap, especially when these kids have been waiting for the opporutnity to play in Dallas Cup for several years.

    I wonder if this is also affecting other age groups.


    It looks like Solar got screwed in the 96 age group also. They finished 3rd but the Texans hold spots 4 and 7 so those teams would go. The 7th place team only won 1 game. I am a big 96 DTRS fan but Solar is a much better team and has 6 more wins against the same compition. I thought the 97 thing was bad but this is a travesty of the selection process. These are the only two age groups affected.

    dreambig

    Posts: 45
    Join date: 2009-06-22

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  dreambig on Fri Dec 04, 2009 5:18 pm

    Tequilapark wrote:
    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    True, think you are upset now? wait to see if Solar does get invited because a spot opens up and then its the 1st, 2nd, 3rd 4th and 6th place teams going, and Blue stays home.

    This is crap, especially when these kids have been waiting for the opporutnity to play in Dallas Cup for several years.

    I wonder if this is also affecting other age groups.

    Yes...I think it will also affect U17 (at least). There are six local U17 Dallas Cup invitations allotted as follows:


    • Four go to USSF Academy Teams
    • One to 1st Place CL team (DTxnRed)
    • One to host club team (5th place DTxnRedWest)

    Left out...2nd place Solar (who tied in points with 1st place, but lost in Goal Differential).
    IMO...if Dallas Cup qualifications were going to be changed this year, they should have been set BEFORE Fall season started. Otherwise, leave the old qualifications in place with host club getting 1 invitation for any of their D1 teams. Changing "host club" invites AFTER the standings were EARNED is dishonorable. Dallas Cup sold out and should just go ahead and change their name to Texans Cup. It all turns my stomach....

    clueless

    Posts: 445
    Join date: 2009-08-06

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  clueless on Fri Dec 04, 2009 5:35 pm

    I'm heartbroken for Solar, winning a contest only to find out (after the contest) that the rules changed is just reprehensible. DTR players should be rightly excited. They still had a shot at a top four spot in the last week so, it's not that they weren't competitive at all and, in fact, for part of the season, they were arguably the best team playing. Just hard to fathom an age-old standard changes that late in the game.
    I was looking for a way to show it to everyone the pdf, the website shows this convenient message:


    Qualification Procedures for Dallas Metro Area Classic League Teams Dallas Cup Qualification procedures will be available prior to the start of Round One of the 2009-2010 Season, unless it doesn't benefit the club that sponsors the tournament, in that event, the procedures will be available upon the completion of Round One of the 2009-2010 Season.


    The table didn't work in my cut/paste out of PDF.

    November 23, 2009


    To: Classic League Division One Teams
    Dallas Area USSF Developmental Academy Teams

    Subject: 2010 Dr Pepper Dallas Cup XXXI Participation-Dallas Metro Area Teams

    Things Change. This is true in our daily lives and it is most certainly true with youth soccer here in the Dallas Metro Area. I have been involved with youth soccer here in Dallas for the past 30 years. Initially, like many of you, as a parent/volunteer with a son playing under 6 recreational soccer and then over the years as a team manager for his club team, tournament director for 2 different tournaments, Executive Director of one of the largest youth soccer associations in the area and for the past 15 years Tournament Manager of the Dallas Cup. In all these years I have seen many changes take place and for the most part the changes have been good for the sport and most importantly for the players.

    Within the past year two major changes took place. The four largest clubs in the Dallas Metro Area joined the USSF Developmental Academy and the Texas Longhorns SC resigned as the Dallas Cup Host Club and a replacement club was needed. These two changes unwittingly created major issues for the Dallas Cup relating to how many teams and which teams will initially be invited to participate in the tournament each year. A lot of thought and discussion went into finding an equitable way to determine how many teams and which teams would receive invitations to participate in the Dr Pepper Dallas Cup XXXI-2010 tournament. You will see the results of these deliberations on the following pages.

    Your thoughts and suggestions for any additional changes are always welcome but please understand they would be considered for the 2011 tournament at the earliest. The enclosed procedures and decisions will be review by the Dallas Cup staff after the 2010 event is concluded.

    If you should have any questions please feel free to contact me. I will do my best to provide you with an answer.

    Best regards,
    Randy Jones
    Tournament Manager


    Dr Pepper Dallas Cup XXXI
    (MARCH 28-APRIL 4, 2010)
    DEFINITIONS & PROCEDURES
    (1) Definition of Dallas Metro Area Teams: Teams that are considered to be Dallas Metro Area teams and will be invited to
    participate in the Dallas Cup are those teams from the Host Club, teams that compete in the Classic League Division One and teams that are members of the USSF Developmental Academy. Dallas Metro Area Teams are further defined as those teams
    on which the majority of the players reside within the DFW Metro Area and which can provide the HomeStay Program for international teams on a reasonable basis as defined by the Dallas Cup. This definition precludes teams/clubs from areas such as Wichita Falls, Tyler, Midland/Odessa, etc. from being considered for selection to participate in the Dallas Cup regardless of where they compete in league play or their final position in league play.
    (2) The Dallas Cup Host Club: Based on the amount of responsibility assumed by the Host Club the club will receive two (2) automatic invitations in each Dallas Cup age group (U19-U13). In the Under 19 and Under 17 Dallas Cup age groups the
    selections will be a USSF Developmental Academy team and one other Host Club team from Classic League Division One regardless of finishing position after Round One. If the Host Club does not have a team in either the Under 19 or Under 17 age
    groups in Division One the automatic invitations will not apply to any other Host Club team and will revert to selection from other
    Classic League Division One teams based on order of finish after completion of Round One. In the Under 16 through Under 13
    age groups the two automatic invitations will be selected from Classic League Division One provided the two teams finish no
    lower than 7th place. If the Host Club does not have enough teams in the Under 16 through Under 13 age groups that meet this criteria to accept the automatic invitations the invitations will not apply to any other Host Club team and will revert to selection from
    other Classic League Division One teams based on order of finish after completion of Round One. Completion of Round One is when each team has played the other 9 teams in their age group for the first time. Final results for each age group will be determined by the Classic League after all Classic League tie-breakers, if needed, are applied.
    (3) USSF Developmental Academy Teams: The remaining three U17/18 Academy teams will receive an invitation in the Dallas Cup Under 19 age group and no other and the remaining three U15/U16 Academy teams will receive an invitation in the Dallas
    Cup Under 17 age group and no other.
    (4) Completion of Dallas Cup Age Groups: Once invitations are determined for the Host Club teams in each of the Dallas Cup age groups and USSF Academy teams in the U19 and U17 age groups each group will be completed per the table below with the next highest finishing Classic League Division One team(s). Special Note: The total number of teams invited in any Dallas Cup age group shall not exceed the total number of four team brackets for that age group in the Dallas Cup tournament even if the number of teams falls below the minimum number shown above.
    (5) Alternate Pool Teams: Once each Dallas Cup age group is initially completed, the next two (2) highest finishing teams from
    the Classic League Division One will be placed in an alternate pool. The alternate pool may also include International teams and
    USA teams from outside the Dallas Metro Area. If deemed necessary by the Dallas Cup Selection Committee, alternate pool
    teams may ultimately receive an invitation to participate in the Dallas Cup. The team actually selected will be determined based
    on need and circumstances as well as performance as defined by the Dallas Cup.
    (6) Super Group Consideration: Selection of a Dallas Metro Area team for the Super Group is at the sole discretion of the Dallas
    Cup Selection Committee regardless of affiliation and/or competitive performance in league and tournament play.
    (7) Dallas Cup Age Groups for Dr Pepper Dallas Cup XXXI:
    Under 19 for players born August 1, 1990 and later Under 17 for players born August 1, 1992 and later Under 16 for players born August 1, 1993 and later Under 15 for players born August 1, 1994 and later Under 14 for players born August 1, 1995 and later Under 13 for players born August 1, 1996 and later

    GENERAL INFORMATION & REQUIREMENTS
    (1) All Dallas Metro Area teams that accept the invitation to participate in the Dallas Cup are required to provide the HomeStay Program for an international team if requested by the Dallas Cup office. Participating teams should be prepared to have a minimum of twelve (12) homes/families available to provide the HomeStay Program. The majority of the international teams will arrive on the Friday before the tournament begins and depart on the Monday morning after the conclusion of the tournament. There may be occasions where the international team may have to arrive earlier and/or stay later in order to secure a significantly cheaper airfare. If this situation occurs the Dallas Cup office will advise the Dallas team’s HomeStay Coordinator to work out the details. All individuals (18 and older including players) that are involved with the Dallas Cup HomeStay Program will be required to complete the online process for a Criminal Background Check. Each participating Dallas Metro Area team will receive an “All Tournament Stadium” pass for the coach and manager. The players on each participating Dallas Metro area team will receive a “Player Stadium Pass”. If a participating Dallas Metro Area team is selected to provide the HomeStay program for an international team and the team actually arrives for the tournament the Dallas Metro Area team will also receive an additional thirty six (36) “All Tournament Stadium passes which can be used in any manner at the team’s discretion. If a participating Dallas Metro Area team is not selected to provide the HomeStay Program or if an assigned international team does not arrive the Dallas Metro Area team(s) will be required to provide 120 man hours of volunteer time per team prior to or during the tournament. Additional “All Tournament Stadium Passes” will be provided per Dallas Cup guidelines to individuals that actually perform the volunteer work.
    (2) The entry fee for Dallas Metro area teams is $800 per team for the 2010 tournament. This fee is a $200 reduction on the normal fee of $1000 required of all other participating teams. This fee is due and payable when notified by the Dallas Cup office.

    (3) Dallas Metro Area participating teams will be notified when to complete the online application/registration process. All teams are asked not to do anything until receiving instructions from the Dallas Cup office. This notification will normally occur sometime in
    November.
    (4) Dallas Metro Area Clubs that have teams participating in the Dallas Cup will be provided with a fund raising opportunity which
    will benefit the club and also provide support to the tournament. This fund raising opportunity is related to the All Tournament
    Season Passes and single day Stadium Tickets. These tickets will be offered to the club at a 50% discount from face value.
    The club may resell these tickets at any price they determine which does not exceed the stated face value. The club may also
    use these tickets in any other non-reselling way that they see fit.

    IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CONTACT
    Randy Jones, Tournament Manager
    12700 Park Central Drive, Suite 507
    Dallas, Texas 75251
    Phone (214) 221-3636 E-mail ( randy@dallascup.com )
    (These Procedures Are Subject To Change At Any Time If Deemed Necessary By The Dallas Cup)
    11-21-09

    True10

    Posts: 492
    Join date: 2009-06-22
    Location: No really, where am I

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  True10 on Fri Dec 04, 2009 5:48 pm

    I see a pattern. Solar getting screwed. Did KS steal HN's girlfriend years ago?

    crabman

    Posts: 1
    Join date: 2009-06-21
    Location: Ernie's Crab Shack

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  crabman on Fri Dec 04, 2009 6:54 pm

    Where does it say that Texans is the host club?

    dreambig

    Posts: 45
    Join date: 2009-06-22

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  dreambig on Fri Dec 04, 2009 7:45 pm

    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.

    I agree. To me, there is a basic, simple, universal principle of fairness - you don't change the rules after the games have been played. Nothing justifies breaking that principle. Not money (Dallas Cup), nor arrogance and selfishness (Texans). Breaking that principle tarnishes their integrity. But apparently in this case, that does not matter to the parties involved.

    rantnrave

    Posts: 123
    Join date: 2009-10-02

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  rantnrave on Fri Dec 04, 2009 8:23 pm

    go99 wrote:I feel bad for the boys, but I am adding this to my stack of things to hold against HN, texans, and the N texas soccer mafia

    go99,
    Please do not take this the wrong way. But, for once, I AGREE WITH YOU ON THIS!

    THE NEEDLE

    Posts: 219
    Join date: 2009-08-20
    Location: Under skin

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  THE NEEDLE on Fri Dec 04, 2009 10:02 pm

    crabman wrote:Where does it say that Texans is the host club?

    I have heard the Texans are to be the host, but the Dallas Cup website still has lots of refernces to the Longhorns Soccer Club as the host. Looks like they need to get their website updated if the Texans have taken over.

    sillymom

    Posts: 101
    Join date: 2009-09-11

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  sillymom on Sat Dec 05, 2009 7:57 am

    rantnrave wrote:
    go99 wrote:I feel bad for the boys, but I am adding this to my stack of things to hold against HN, texans, and the N texas soccer mafia

    go99,
    Please do not take this the wrong way. But, for once, I AGREE WITH YOU ON THIS!


    I concur. This is just wrong and disgusting. What does it teach the kids? Have the adults who changed the rules thought about this. But then again I don't think they care. Just another reason why my kids will never play for the devil and his club!!!!

    I wonder how KS is taking this news?

    sillymom

    Posts: 101
    Join date: 2009-09-11

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  sillymom on Sat Dec 05, 2009 8:08 am

    True10 wrote:
    Tequilapark wrote:
    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    True, think you are upset now? wait to see if Solar does get invited because a spot opens up and then its the 1st, 2nd, 3rd 4th and 6th place teams going, and Blue stays home.

    This is crap, especially when these kids have been waiting for the opporutnity to play in Dallas Cup for several years.

    I wonder if this is also affecting other age groups.


    It looks like Solar got screwed in the 96 age group also. They finished 3rd but the Texans hold spots 4 and 7 so those teams would go. The 7th place team only won 1 game. I am a big 96 DTRS fan but Solar is a much better team and has 6 more wins against the same compition. I thought the 97 thing was bad but this is a travesty of the selection process. These are the only two age groups affected.


    How does a 7th place team take the place of a 3rd place team. The 4th place team is a Texans Red team. How would the 7th place team jump over the 4th place team and take the place of the 3rd place team. How is this right

    Manbearpig

    Posts: 4
    Join date: 2009-12-04

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Manbearpig on Sat Dec 05, 2009 10:20 am

    Enough said...likely nothing will be done about it anyway.


    Last edited by Manbearpig on Sun Dec 06, 2009 10:09 pm; edited 1 time in total

    clueless

    Posts: 445
    Join date: 2009-08-06

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  clueless on Sat Dec 05, 2009 10:39 am

    sillymom wrote:
    True10 wrote:
    Tequilapark wrote:
    True10 wrote:Punka** Dallas Texans. They could not win a spot so they buy a spot. DTRS, FCD, Andro Red and Solar go out and win spots but Solar gets screwed because DTR/Hassan who get sent packing but have the sponsorship(money) to get themselves an underserved spot. Like them or hate them, Dallas Texans have had a history winning. They would go out beat teams on the field but this is just a blatant change of rules to benefit the club. Dallas Cup organizers should a shame to let this happen. I wonder if anybody had the guts to tell the Solar players to their faces that they are not going to get to participate in the Dallas Cup because your spot has been bought by a team 2 places below your own. I cannot imagine how those kids feel after playing so hard in the fall and thinking they qualified and get the news that your not in. I guess it is not about the kids after all. I am truly disgusted.


    True, think you are upset now? wait to see if Solar does get invited because a spot opens up and then its the 1st, 2nd, 3rd 4th and 6th place teams going, and Blue stays home.

    This is crap, especially when these kids have been waiting for the opporutnity to play in Dallas Cup for several years.

    I wonder if this is also affecting other age groups.


    It looks like Solar got screwed in the 96 age group also. They finished 3rd but the Texans hold spots 4 and 7 so those teams would go. The 7th place team only won 1 game. I am a big 96 DTRS fan but Solar is a much better team and has 6 more wins against the same compition. I thought the 97 thing was bad but this is a travesty of the selection process. These are the only two age groups affected.


    How does a 7th place team take the place of a 3rd place team. The 4th place team is a Texans Red team. How would the 7th place team jump over the 4th place team and take the place of the 3rd place team. How is this right


    That one is particularly egregious as the 4th place Texans team is arguably as good as the #1 team and the 3rd place Solar team is right there with them. I haven't seen the 7th place team play - but, based upon record - it doesn't look quite up to par.
    Interesting moral/ethical dilemma presented by manbearpig - wonder if any parent would be willing to stand up to their coach/DOC/czar and explain why you don't think this is right, if, that's how you feel. If you were holding a lottery ticket, the number is drawn and you don't lose, then, after someone sees your ticket, they change the numbers to yours - what would you do? Keeping in mind the original winner was thinking they had already hit the jackpot.
    I respectfully disagree at the broad-brush painting of the kids as not being 'good kids' - you can't state with any grounding, that the kids are evil and bad as you state. Just because you don't agree with their club/coach. I question the tournament, not the club/coach/kids. The coach is doing his job by negotiating this into the hosting agreement, the tournament is the one that seems to have lost their sense of fairness.

    Manbearpig

    Posts: 4
    Join date: 2009-12-04

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Manbearpig on Sat Dec 05, 2009 10:51 am

    Enough Said.


    Last edited by Manbearpig on Sun Dec 06, 2009 10:10 pm; edited 1 time in total

    THE NEEDLE

    Posts: 219
    Join date: 2009-08-20
    Location: Under skin

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  THE NEEDLE on Sat Dec 05, 2009 11:05 am

    Dallas Cup needs to explain WHY they went from the host club, previously the Longhorns, getting 1 bye per age group if they had a D1 team to 2 teams per age group assuming they are in the top 7 of D1.
    Dallas Cup needs to announce formally who the host club is for this year. Also clarify will that club also be the host club on a semi-permanent basis or will it rotate?
    These are important questions. Technically, Dallas Cup can say they did not change the qualify rules becasue they were never formally stated. Obviously, most of us assumed they would use the same basic formula as they had in the past. I understand the need to modify the process for the older groups. I disagree with the changes for U13-U16.

    Butters

    Posts: 9
    Join date: 2009-12-05

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Butters on Sat Dec 05, 2009 11:31 am

    Manbearpig wrote:
    Onetime wrote:The kids are upset, they worked hard in winning their last 2 games to qualify, but unfortunately this is the new system we have to live with concerning Dallas Cup. As I told my son, use this as motivation as you continue to develop as a soccer player. One thing I ask, please don't hold this against the kids on 97DTR, they are a great group of kids and parents, and I am sure they will do their best to represent our league at Dallas Cup.


    A great group of kids and parents????? I think you miss the point entirely. 1. The parents are more guilty than HN if they go along with this....and they will because they are worse than HN. There is no moral barrier that these people will not blast themselves through for little Johnny and HN knows that about them or they wouldn't be playing for him. God knows his choice of players is only 40% about their play ability, the rest is pocket book, sex appeal and "willingness". 2. These may have been good kids at age 1 but look at what these kids have been taught for the past 5 to 10 years and you will see that these are NOT "good kids". These kids are scarier than than the Taliban. Dont fool yourself. WAKE UP !!!! You can't hug a pig and expect not to get dirty and smell bad. Let's sit back and watch how many of these parents tell HN "No my kids character is more important to me than anything else...my kids will not be part of this dishonesty." Its not gonna happen but if by some stroke of goodness it does I will be the first to say "here we have a good kid and a good family" and I will give that family hero status in my book from here on out. The Texans parents are DIRTY and disgusting for allowing this to happen. Dont hide behind "the DEVIL made me do it". Be ashamed and own up to it.
    This type of thing is going to create a lot more dishonesty and animosity on the future between players and teams. Thats not good for the sport and its growth AT ALL. The Dallas cup committee whoever they are have just hurt the Dallas cup as well. Think about how much confidence this destroys in the cup as a whole. You cannot say AT ALL that the Cup is above reproach from this point on. No one can. So if your kids on a team that wins the thing you start to ask yourself. "were we the better team"?? I think this whole thing is real bad and I dont think this is over yet.


    Very well spoken. I can say from personal experience with my sons old Texans team that much of what you are saying is true. I know that many of those kids are good kids though. My son is still friends with a lot of them. I know also that some of them are very embarrassed about the way this has gone and a few are even questioning what they should do from what I hear. I think the Dallas Cup needs to give an explanation about the rules change. This is potentially going to affect my sons team and I would like to know why they didn't make the rules changes at the beginning of the season instead of waiting until now. I personally like Hassans brutal style (please dont kill me for saying that) and I think if you are prepared to deal with that you will do better when you have a kid on the Texans teams. Its hard for the rest of the world to stomach. But I agree that he can't do a thing without the backing of the parents.
    By the way I see you're a south park fan? You need to get an Avatar for Manbearpig. I am guessing thats where you got that or are you really a fan of Al Gore? Surprised)

    plantit

    Posts: 687
    Join date: 2009-06-30
    Location: under the bleechers seeing more butts

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  plantit on Sat Dec 05, 2009 12:27 pm

    There could be a very easy fix to all of this . First. FCDallas pull the venue PHP.

    Second, all The other large clubs boycott dallas cup. I think after the " Hosing" Solar took they would be first in line. Then have the other big 3 set up an international tournament in dallas , inviting teams from Europe, Latin america. Asia, And africa. Third designate a venue in our metroplex to each of these continents. Help each continent transform this venue into a cultural interpretation of Soccer in that continent.Have that host continent stay at that venue.

    Third hire cultural businesses from the metroplex to aide in the transformation with food , dancers, programs ect. Also a win win for exposer of our diverse community.

    Fourth have ,FCD, Solar, Andro use their contacts in the americas to invite high quality teams into the metroplex with the promise of playing one game in each venue. Thereby giving them a unpresidented soccer expierence.The lure to the countries? Cheap entry fees. an unpresidented hosting environment, a chance to expose their culture. The lure for the america's? A chance to play 4 different teams from four different parts of the world. Have a token gift exchange between countries at each venue. Who needs more tacky trophies. Return the game to what it is " beautiful " not for something but about something. If you want a result ,the top 2 team in each continent represents that continent playing the top point leaders that have traveled venue to venue. Champions are awarded by continant I.E Solar was africa champs,sweden was europe champs Ect,Ect.

    By year 2, people will be saying dallas cup what? dallas cup who? Oh ya ! thats a texans tournament.

    Manbearpig

    Posts: 4
    Join date: 2009-12-04

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  Manbearpig on Sat Dec 05, 2009 12:49 pm

    Enough Said


    Last edited by Manbearpig on Sun Dec 06, 2009 10:10 pm; edited 1 time in total

    b0013

    Posts: 281
    Join date: 2009-06-20

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  b0013 on Sat Dec 05, 2009 12:55 pm

    So , all teams coming in will have to stay at hotels in Farmers Branch...?

    THE NEEDLE

    Posts: 219
    Join date: 2009-08-20
    Location: Under skin

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  THE NEEDLE on Sat Dec 05, 2009 1:43 pm

    b0013 wrote:So , all teams coming in will have to stay at hotels in Farmers Branch...?

    Yes, but they also have to agree to only speak english.

    clueless

    Posts: 445
    Join date: 2009-08-06

    Re: Dallas Cup - moral/ethical dilemma

    Post  clueless on Sat Dec 05, 2009 3:07 pm

    plantit wrote:There could be a very easy fix to all of this . First. FCDallas pull the venue PHP.

    Second, all The other large clubs boycott dallas cup. I think after the " Hosing" Solar took they would be first in line. Then have the other big 3 set up an international tournament in dallas , inviting teams from Europe, Latin america. Asia, And africa. Third designate a venue in our metroplex to each of these continents. Help each continent transform this venue into a cultural interpretation of Soccer in that continent.Have that host continent stay at that venue.

    Third hire cultural businesses from the metroplex to aide in the transformation with food , dancers, programs ect. Also a win win for exposer of our diverse community.

    Fourth have ,FCD, Solar, Andro use their contacts in the americas to invite high quality teams into the metroplex with the promise of playing one game in each venue. Thereby giving them a unpresidented soccer expierence.The lure to the countries? Cheap entry fees. an unpresidented hosting environment, a chance to expose their culture. The lure for the america's? A chance to play 4 different teams from four different parts of the world. Have a token gift exchange between countries at each venue. Who needs more tacky trophies. Return the game to what it is " beautiful " not for something but about something. If you want a result ,the top 2 team in each continent represents that continent playing the top point leaders that have traveled venue to venue. Champions are awarded by continant I.E Solar was africa champs,sweden was europe champs Ect,Ect.

    By year 2, people will be saying dallas cup what? dallas cup who? Oh ya ! thats a texans tournament.

    I think the easier solution would be, for this year, invite the top four + texans - it certainly wouldn't detract from the competitiveness. This would resolve the current injustice and everyone would know the selection process in the future.
    I don't think HN could prevent the tournament from happening, but he could certainly create his own venue and pull all his teams out of it - which would benefit no one. Was the DCup change to Nike before or after (due to) the Texans sponsorship? Obviously, the tournament needs sponsorship and administration -so, the likely candidate would be the largest, most powerful club, again, nothing wrong with what HN nor Texans did, IMO (like negotiating anything).
    It does make one wonder if this will erode the Dallas Cups draw and relevancy in a way similar to ODP and even Classic league are apparently tracking. With this deal, Texans have a much larger appeal for many seeking a new D1 home, IMO.
    About the only plus side is there is something worthy of commentary on this site!

      Current date/time is Wed May 23, 2012 2:27 am